PDA

View Full Version : Trust and rivalries between China and the US



Maciamo
Nov 18, 2005, 10:05
This article is an excellent summary of the present Sino-American relations.

The Economist : Looking for common ground (http://www.economist.com/agenda/displaystory.cfm?story_id=5165029)

A few questions for discussions :

1) Is the US trying to encircle China militarily ?

2) Does the USA see China as a real threat, or is it just being careful ?

3) Would the PRC ever invade Taiwan, eventhough it may lead to a war with the US, and possibly also Japan ?

4) Is it a good thing for the US to manufacture its own products in China ? It certainly helps corporations make bigger profits, but also creates unemployment in the US.

4321go
Nov 18, 2005, 16:29
About 1>, Yes ,of course. or ,what will U.S do to spread so many amry around China as the pic. show?

http://www.economist.com/images/ga/2005w47/Map.gif

About 2>, Not absolutely,there are two part of opinion in the U.S. Many American are friendly to China!

About 3>, That depends on Taiwan's attitude or action, and I believe it will surely drag U.S and Japan in.And,I doubt it will have a war! because,see this:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_Pan-Blue_visits_to_mainland_China.
Treat TaiWan like to treat a naughty child. Surely ,parentes don't want to beat their children,so always gally them ! but if the child is too naughty,then ,parentes will beat him!

And the last one:I have no ideas! but one thing I can confirm is the unemployment in China is higher than U.S.

bossel
Nov 19, 2005, 09:36
1) Is the US trying to encircle China militarily ?
Nope, why should they?


2) Does the USA see China as a real threat, or is it just being careful ?
As a potential threat, I suppose.


3) Would the PRC ever invade Taiwan, eventhough it may lead to a war with the US, and possibly also Japan ?
Perhaps, there are enough idiots in the PLA & the PRC who would. The question is "How much influence do these idiots have?"


4) Is it a good thing for the US to manufacture its own products in China ? It certainly helps corporations make bigger profits, but also creates unemployment in the US.
That's globalisation for you. I doubt that we should return (well, return, has it ever really disappeared?) to mercantilism or protectionism.

Nucifera
Dec 22, 2005, 20:08
1) Is the US trying to encircle China militarily ?
Yes. Indeed. The alliance of US-Japan is used for that.

2) Does the USA see China as a real threat, or is it just being careful ?
Potential threat.

3) Would the PRC ever invade Taiwan, eventhough it may lead to a war with the US, and possibly also Japan ?
China reunification will come one day, this is inevitable. But the method of reunify is rather using peaceful way than force.

4) Is it a good thing for the US to manufacture its own products in China ? It certainly helps corporations make bigger profits, but also creates unemployment in the US.
Since China joined WTO, US has no reason to pratice it protectionism from China. Yes. Globalization~~~~





:blush:

Wang
Dec 27, 2005, 09:11
1) Is the US trying to encircle China militarily ?

Partly not fully because China has more than 1,3 billion people, military spending has been increasing a lot in the last 17 years and China's intentions of what it'll exactly do with such a huge army isn't clear.

2) Does the USA see China as a real threat, or is it just being careful ?

A possible threat to the balance and stability of the region and the world.

3) Would the PRC ever invade Taiwan, eventhough it may lead to a war with the US, and possibly also Japan ?

I'm afraid yes. I hope all the people in Taiwan can decide their future eventually on their own.

4) Is it a good thing for the US to manufacture its own products in China ? It certainly helps corporations make bigger profits, but also creates unemployment in the US.

There should be a balance between what is produced in other countries and the unemployment that's therefore being created.

mingo
Apr 25, 2006, 16:03
This article is an excellent summary of the present Sino-American relations.
The Economist : Looking for common ground (http://www.economist.com/agenda/displaystory.cfm?story_id=5165029)
A few questions for discussions :
1) Is the US trying to encircle China militarily ?
2) Does the USA see China as a real threat, or is it just being careful ?
3) Would the PRC ever invade Taiwan, eventhough it may lead to a war with the US, and possibly also Japan ?
4) Is it a good thing for the US to manufacture its own products in China ? It certainly helps corporations make bigger profits, but also creates unemployment in the US.
1. not sure, the general public don't know and can't know what they are planning in pentagon. but u can't call it a circle withou russia. so relax, and don't worry about it.

2. potential threat to what is unclear?
threat to US security? maybe not..
threat to world dominance? maybe, GOP Amercians do like to be the dicatator of world (no UN), at least the US militray do want to be the one and only one supreme force on the planet.
threat to regional stablilty? depends, if taiwan factor counts, maybe yes, but expecting china to invade other nations(not include ROC) is very unlikely.

3. depends on the number of idiots on both side, but as long as they can sit down and talk, there won't be any invasion, people in PRC didn't want to see bloodshed either.. so do rest of the world.

4. globlization is a good one, however, the welfare of the third nations should be our concern in the near future instead of the unemployment rate of US. and it will help global security too..





[I]3) Would the PRC ever invade Taiwan, eventhough it may lead to a war with the US, and possibly also Japan ?
I'm afraid yes. I hope all the people in Taiwan can decide their future eventually on their own.

it all depend on you, my friend. the number of you and your anti-ROC friends will be a key factor to determine how many idiots and how much is their influence in PLA. it's called Yin-Yang :p
sit down and have some talk will be a much better choice :relief: I believe you still have a ROC passport/ID right?

Feb 3, 2007, 00:34
1) Is the US trying to encircle China militarily ?
In fact,since PRC was born,USA never stopped encircling China--especially on the Pacific Ocean.

2) Does the USA see China as a real threat, or is it just being careful ?
I think China's not strong enough to be a real threat of USA, maybe in the future~

3) Would the PRC ever invade Taiwan, eventhough it may lead to a war with the US, and possibly also Japan ?
firstly,if PRC attacks Taiwan-it's not "invade"..secondary,China hasn't invaded any country in last 700years,and It doesn't have the need to invade.Unless others invade China ,Chinese will do anything to defend their motherland-no matter how powerful the enrmy is.

4) Is it a good thing for the US to manufacture its own products in China ? It certainly helps corporations make bigger profits, but also creates unemployment in the US.
Generally,what caused unenployment are usually some faluts in the market of
one country---but the government always says it's caused by other nation's
products---

pipokun
Feb 3, 2007, 18:00
3) Would the PRC ever invade Taiwan, eventhough it may lead to a war with the US, and possibly also Japan ?
firstly,if PRC attacks Taiwan-it's not "invade"..secondary,China hasn't invaded any country in last 700years,and It doesn't have the need to invade.Unless others invade China ,Chinese will do anything to defend their motherland-no matter how powerful the enrmy is.

What do you think the recent summit talk between China and Korea?
I think the ancient Goguryeo was just a vassel state, but no matter how you love the history, they should talk about more current issues. At least, Chinese people came to know how Korean people love their history.

Feb 3, 2007, 23:46
What do you think the recent summit talk between China and Korea?
I think the ancient Goguryeo was just a vassel state, but no matter how you love the history, they should talk about more current issues. At least, Chinese people came to know how Korean people love their history.

For the history--Korea is just korea,How can you compare China with Korea!
If so, you can compare Japan with Greece!

cnchance
Apr 4, 2007, 18:00
1) Is the US trying to encircle China militarily ?
Yes!
2) Does the USA see China as a real threat, or is it just being careful ?
Yes! A potential threat.
3) Would the PRC ever invade Taiwan, eventhough it may lead to a war with the US, and possibly also Japan ?
The PRC will never invade Taiwan.Taiwan is part of China,there is no doubt that China will get reunification on day.Whether there will be a war between Mainland and Taiwan,it depends on the USA's attitude.
4) Is it a good thing for the US to manufacture its own products in China ? It certainly helps corporations make bigger profits, but also creates unemployment in the US.
Yes! Globalism is good for the two sides.